نوع مقاله : علمی-پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Background and Objective: Theory of mind is a core component of social cognition that contributes to interpersonal interactions. This study compared affective and cognitive theory of mind components sarcastic remarks, human action, and physical event between girls and boys lower secondary school students.
Method: This causal-comparative study included 300 students selected through multistage cluster random sampling from public lower secondary schools in Masjed Soleyman, Iran. Data were collected using the Reading the Mind in the Eyes Test (Baron-Cohen et al., 2001) and the Mentalistic Interpretations Task (Channon et al., 2005). Multivariate analysis of variance and post hoc tests were used for data analysis.
Findings: A significant gender difference was found in affective theory of mind and cognitive theory of mind components (Wilks’ Lambda = .88, F = 9.9, p ≤ .05). Univariate analyses indicated significant differences in affective theory of mind and in the human action and physical event components, whereas the difference in sarcastic remarks was not significant. Bonferroni-adjusted comparisons supported these findings.
Conclusion: Girls outperformed boys in affective theory of mind and selected cognitive theory of mind components. The findings may inform the development of school based social and emotional empowerment programs for adolescents.
Keywords: Social Cognition, Theory of Mind, Affective Theory of Mind, Cognitive Theory of Mind, High School.
Introduction
Social cognition comprises a set of cognitive processes that underpin and organize interpersonal interaction in social environments (Desatnik et al., 2023). Theory of Mind is one of the most important key concepts of this psychological construct. Theory of Mind has been defined by Osterhaus et al (2025) as a cognitive ability to observe and understand mental states, to recognize desires, emotions, beliefs, and intentions of oneself and others. This ability begins to emerge in a child’s cognitive structure around ages 3 to 4 and given the importance of Theory of Mind as the basis for shaping a child’s thinking, questions exist regarding the growth, development, and functioning of this variable during adolescence (Osterhaus & Bosacki, 2022). Moreover, adolescence is one of the most important stage of development, in which rapid physical, cognitive, and social-emotional changes increase vulnerability and engagement in risky behaviors (Pike et al., 2024). Adenzato et al (2017) have referred to gender differences in social cognition: girls tend to attend to social cues emotionally, whereas boys examine interpersonal social situations in a systematic and evaluative manner. The difference between social cognition and the way of responding to social cues between girls and boys has led to one of the conceptual divisions of Theory of Mind into affective and cognitive dimensions, which has gained considerable importance in the theoretical and research foundations of this variable. Affective Theory of Mind refers to inferring emotional states, while Cognitive Theory of Mind refers to inferring the beliefs and ideas of the individual (Chan, 2025). With a look at the theoretical and empirical foundations of Theory of Mind as one of the most influential dimensions of social cognition, its prominent role in interpretations, psychological inferences, and social adaptation of adolescents in educational settings is recognized. Accordingly, the aim of this study is to answer this question: Is there a significant difference between high school girls and boys in terms of the variables of affective Theory of Mind and cognitive Theory of Mind?
Method
The current study uses a comparative design. The population comprises all female and male students of first-year (lower secondary) high schools of Masjed Soleyman town during the 2023–2024 academic year, selected via a multi-stage random sampling method. The sample size was 300 individuals (150 girls and 150 boys). They were assessed with two instruments: (a) a computerized revised version of the Reading the Mind in the Eyes Test by Baron-Cohen et al. (2001) and (b) the Mentalistic Interpretations Task. Data were analyzed using SPSS 24. To analyze the data, multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) was employed.
Discussion
Considering the aim of the present study to determine whether there are differences between female and male high school students in affective Theory of Mind and cognitive Theory of Mind, the results of the multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) used to answer the first research question indicate that this multivariate test—having greater statistical power than its univariate counterpart for detecting between-group differences—was significant. The results of separate univariate analyses for each of the four variables using one-way ANOVA between groups showed that the affective domain of Theory of Mind and the two components of “human action” and “physical event” are significant between the female and male students. Subsequently, supplementary MANOVA analyses and assessment of effect sizes indicate that, after adjusting the alpha level with the Bonferroni correction, three variables of affective Theory of Mind and the two components of human action and physical event are significant, while the component of sarcastic remarks is not significant. In examining the power of the four variables to discriminate between the two groups of female and male students, the effect sizes show that affective Theory of Mind has the greatest discriminating power, and the component of sarcastic remarks has the least. Overall, during adolescence accompanied by emotional, cognitive, and physiological changes the affective component of Theory of Mind holds particular importance within adolescents’ inferential framework for constructing their social-interactive environment. The results obtained in this study, in relation to the theoretical foundations of the construct of social cognition, show that the Theory of Mind in general and its affective and cognitive dimensions in particular, as well as the neurocognitive bases of the brain underpin the theoretical link of Theory of Mind (Adenzato et al., 2017; Chan, 2025; Gabriel et al., 2021;). By examining and comparing the results of the present study with existing research,
Conclusion
Identifying the various affective and cognitive dimensions of Theory of Mind during adolescence leads to a more precise understanding of students’ mental-state attributions (internalized and interpersonal) in this age group. Recognizing mental-state attributions based on the affective and cognitive components of Theory of Mind informs teachers and school staff about how each student responds to environmental educational stimuli around them. This insight can, using results from studies like this, enable categorizing students into affective and cognitive groups and consider which of these two dimensions is more heavily used in their individual analyses and interpretations. It also clarifies the extent to which these analyses empower in-school teachers to predict students’ future behaviors in social situations and interactions, so that decisions health-promotion and structurally oriented can be made based on the pattern of each Theory of Mind dimension in students’ behavior to foster a healthy social environment.